Temperature control system



March 9, 1937. D. e. TAYLOR 2,073,325

TEMPERATURE CONTROL SYSTEM Filed Sept. 5, 1935 Darzz'e? 6. 1213707 Patented Mar. 9, 1937 TEMPERATURE CONTROL SYSTEM Daniel G. Taylor, Minneapolis, Minn., assignor to Minneapolis-Honeywell Regulator Company, Minneapolis, Minn., a corporation of Delaware Application September 5, 1935, Serial No. 39,299

20 Claims.

This invention relates to temperature control systems of the type disclosed in my co-pending application, Serial No. 512,887, filed February 2, 1931.

The system disclosed in my above referred to co-pending application comprises an outdoor controller responsive to outdoor atmospheric conditions, including temperature, wind and solar radiation for controlling the temperature within the building. Heating means are provided in the building for supplying heat to the building and heating means are also provided in the outdoor controller for supplying heat to the outdoor controller. The two heating means are proporl5 tioned according to the heat losses from the building and from the outdoor controller. A thermostatic device is provided in the outdoor controller for responding to the temperature within the outdoor controller, and when this ther- 20 mostatic device calls for heat both of the heating means are simultaneously energized to deliver heat to the building and to the outdoor controller. Due to the proportional relationship of the heating means with the heat losses-of the building 25 and the outdoor controller a definite temperature relation is maintained within the building and the outdoor controller so that by responding to the temperature of the outdoor controller the thermostatic device maintains a substantially 30 constant or normal temperature within the buildll'lg.

Such a system is of the off and on type, giving intermittent operation of the building heating means and the controller heating means. Due to 35 the intermittent operation of the above referred to system an absolutely straight line temperature relationship cannot be accurately maintained and over-heating during mild weather is sometimes brought about. This failure to maintain an ab- 40 solutely constant temperature and this overheating is caused by the admission at intervals of a full charge of heating fluid, such as steam,

to the radiators or heat exchangers within the building. This full charge of heating fluid inter- 45 mittently admitted tends to cause unevenness of temperature conditions within the building and also tends to increase the radiator temperature Within'the building above the desired value during mild weather, thereby causing over-heating of the building.

It is, therefore, an object of this invention to provide a heating system for a building of the proportioning or modulating type whereby intermittent operation is eliminated, heat is supplied 55 to the building at a steady rate to maintain the building temperature constant, and over-heating of the building during mild weather is prevented.

Whenproportioning the heat delivered to the building according to outdoor atmospheric conditions, it is desirable to proportion also the amount of heat delivered to the outdoor controller whereby a more accurate control of the building temperature is obtained. It is, therefore, another object of this invention to provide means for proportioning or modulating the amount of heat to the outdoor controller as well as to the building.

It is another object of this invention to provide-a temperature control system in control of a temperature changing means for a space wherein there is provided a controller outside of the space including temperature changing means and thermostatic means responsive to the temperature of the controller and wherein the thermostatic means modulates both temperature changing means to maintain the temperature of the space at a fixed predetermined value.

Still another object of this invention is to provide a temperature control system for controlling the heating means of a building wherein the temperature control system comprises an outdoor controller subject to the same atmospheric conditions as the building, and including heating means and thermostatically operated variable resistance means, the heating means of the outdoor controller and the building being proportional to the heat losses from-the outdoor controller and the building, and wherein connections between the variable resistance means and both of the heating means are provided to modulate both of the heating means in accordance with the heat losses from the controller, whereby even temperatures aremaintained within the building and whereby "over-shooting" of the building temperature during mild weather is prevented.

It is a further object of this invention to provide a controller for a heating means including an electric heater and thermostatic means in control of a heating means wherein a variable impedance is operated by the heating means and connected in series with the electric heater for controlling the heating effect of the electric heat.- er, and wherein means are associated with the electric heater for adjusting the heating effect of the electric heater but maintaining the load on the variable impedance constant, whereby the control system may be adjusted to fit each particular installation without rendering the calibration of the control system inaccurate.

'Other objects and advantages will become apparent to those skilled in the art upon reference to the accompanying specification, claims and drawing, in which drawing is diagrammatically illustrated the preferred form of my invention.

My invention is shown to be applied to a building having an outside wall l0, and a plurality of spaces or rooms II and IE to be heated, although the control system may be applied to any space. Located in the rooms or spaces, II and I2 are heat exchangers or radiators l3, which receive a supply of heating fluid, such as steam, from'risers 14, under the control of manually operated shut-off valves l5. The expended heating fluid maybe taken from the heat exchangers or radiators l3 by means of pipes l6 and disposed of in any suitable manner. Leading from some source of heating fluid, such as a constantly energized boiler, or a central power plant, is a supply pipe M. The flow of heating fluid from the supply pipe I? into a pipe I9 is controlled by means of a valve IS, the pipe l9 being connected into a header 20. The risers 89 also connect into the header 20 so that when the valve I8 is moved to an open position heating fluid is delivered from the pipe H to the heat exchangers or radiators l3, and when the valve i8 is moved to a closed position the further supply of heating fluid to the heat exchangers or radiators I3 is prevented.

The valve I8 is adapted to be moved to either extreme closed position or extreme open position, or is adapted to be modulated or positioned at any point intermediate these extreme positions by means of a valve stem 2|. A yoke 22 is secured to the valve stein 2! by means of nuts 23 and 29. The yoke 22 carries a pin 25, to which is secured one end of a pitman 26. The other -end of the pitman 26 is secured to a crank pin 27., mounted on a crank disc 29, which in turn is carried by a shaft 29. The shaft 29, and consequently the valve l8, may be operated by a proportioningmotor of the type shown and described in application Serial No. 673,236, filed by Lewis L. Cunningham on May 27, 1933. v For purposes of illustration in this application, I have shown this proportioning motor to comprise a gear 39 mounted on the shaft 29 and operated through a reduction gear train 3! by motor rotors 32 and 33. Associated with the motor rotors 32 and 39 are field windings 39 and 95, the arrangement being such that when the field winding 95 is energized the valve i8 is moved toward an open position, and when the field winding 35 is energized the valve I8 is moved toward a closed position. Also mounted on the shaft 29 is a bevelled gear 36 which engages a bevelled gear 97, which in turn carries an abutment member 39. The abutment member 98 is preferably made of an insulating material and carries a slider 99 adapted to slide across a balancing potentiometer coil 99. The abutment member 38 also carries fingers 9| and 92. When the abutment member 39 is moved-to an extreme counter-clockwise position the finger-4|. is adapted to engage contact 53 to break contact between the contact 43 and a contact 99. Likewise, upon extreme clockwise movement of theabutment' member 98 the finger 42 engages a contact 55 to break contact between the contact 95 and a contact 46. Therefore, the contacts 43, 49, 95 and 4'6 form limit switches. Movement of the valve l8 towards an open position causes counter-clockwise movement of the abutment member 38, and movement of the valve l8 towards ignated at 59'.

the abutment member 38.

Located outside of the building, so as to respend to the same atmospheric conditions as the building, including temperature, wind and solar radiation, is an outdoor controller generally des- The outdoor controller 50 is shown to comprise a metallic block 5| mounted on a suitable base 52. The block Si is hollowed out and has secured therein a fulcrum 53. Pivotally mounted on this fulcrum 53 is a lever 54 which is moved in a clockwise direction about the fulcrum 53 by means of an adjustable tension spring 55. The tension spring 55 may be suitably adjusted by manual manipulation of the adjusting screw 56. A bellows 51, which may contain a volatile fluid, is located in the block 5i and carries a plunger 58 which engages the lever 59 to move the lever 54 in a counter-clockwise direction about the fulcrum 53 upon an increase in temperature afiecting the bellows 51. A slider 59 is suitably secured to and insulated from the lever 54 so that upon an increase in block temperature affecting the bellows 57 the slider 59 is moved to the left with respect to a potentiometer coil 59 also mounted in the block 5|. Upon a decrease in block temperature the slider 59 is moved toward the right with respect encloses the hollowed out portion of the block- 5l so that the thermostatic bellows 5'? will not be directly affected by outside atmospheric conditions but will respond directly to the temperature of the block 5!. All of the above related parts comprising the outdoor controller 59 may be enclosed within a suitable casing 63 to prevent destruction of the same by the elements.

oppositely acting coils are designated at 55 and 56, these coils controlling an armature 67 which is connected by means of a spring 59. to a pivoted switch arm 69. The pivoted switch arm 99 co-acts with'spaced contacts 119 and H. When the coil 65 is energized more than the coil 66 the switch arm 69 is moved into engagement with the contact to, and when the coil 66 is energized more than the coil 65 the switch arm" are line wires 12 and 13. A primary 19 of a stepdown transformer 15, having a secondary i6, is connected across the line wires 12 and 79. One end of the secondary l6 is-connected by a wire Ti to one end of the coil 65, and likewise the other end of the secondary is connected by a wire 78 to one end of the coil 69. The adjacent ends of the coils B5 and 66 are connected together. The outer end of the coil 95 is connected by a wire 19, a protective resistance 80 and wires 8| and 82 to the left hand end of the pote tioineter coil 60. Likewise, the outer end of th coil 66 is connected by a wire 84, a protective resistance 85, and wires 86 and 81 to the right hand end of the potentiometer coil 69. The junction of wires ill and 82 is connected by a wire 83 to the left hand end of the balancing potentiometer coil 49 and the junction of'wires 86 and 81 is connected that the secondary 76, the coils E5 and lit, the

by a wire 38 to the right hand end of the balancing potentiometer coil 40. The junction of coils 65 and 66 is connected by wires 96, 9i and 92 to the slider 59 associated with the potentiometer coil 60, and to the slider 39 associated with the balancing potentiometer coil 40.

From the above wiring connections it is seen that the upper end of the secondary l6 and the left hand ends of the coil 65, the potentiometer coil 66 and the balancing potentiometer coil til are connected together, and likewise the lower end of the secondary l6 and the right hand ends of the coil $6, the potentiometer coil 8d and the balancing potentiometer coil 4B are also connected together. The junction of coils 55; and 66 and the sliders 59 and 39 are connected together. By reasonof these connections it is seen potentiometer 60 and the balancing potentiometer A8 are connected in parallel.

The contact 1!) is connected by a wire 93 to a small number of turns of the coil-t5, and the contact l l is connected by a wire d tto a small number of turns of the coilfifi. The junction of the wire 84' and the protective resistance 85 is connected by a wire 95 to the limit switch contact 13 and the contact 3 3 cooperating with the contact 33 is connected by a wire 96 to one end of the field'winding 3 Likewise, the junction of wire 19 and the protective resistance 89] is connected by a wire 91 to thecontact '36 of the other limit switch, and the contact 35 associated with the contact 46 is connected by a wire 98 to one end of the field winding 35. The other ends of the field windings 3t and 35 are connected together and by a wire St to the pivoted switch arm 69.

Upon a decrease in block temperature of the outdoor controller 50 as caused by outdoor atmospheric conditions, the slider 5d is'rnoved to the right with respect to the potentiometer coll till. Due to the parallel relationship outlined above, movement of the slider-59 to the right with respect to the potentiometer coil Gil shunts or short-circuits the coil 66 to decrease the energization thereof and increase the energization of the coil 65. This causes movement of the switch arm 69 into engagement with the contact it to complete a circuit from the secondary l5 through wires'lfi', 84 and 95, contacts 43 and 84, wire 9%,

field winding 34, wire 99, switch arm 69, contact 10, wire 93, a small number of turns of the coil 85 and wire Tl back to the secondary I6. Completion of this circuit causes energization of the field winding 34 to move the valve it toward an open position to supply more heat'to thebullding.

Movement of the valve l8 toward an'open position causes left hand movement of the slider 39 with respect to the balancing potentiometer coil 40, which left hand movement causes shortcircuiting of the coil 65 to decrease the energization thereof and increase the energization'of the coil 66, it being remembered that the coil 65 was energized more than the coil 66 by reason of the right hand movement of the sllder 59 with respect to the potentiometer coil Bil. When the slider 39 has moved sufficiently far to the left to r e-balance the coils 65 and 65, the switch arm 69 is moved out of engagement with the contact lll to the mid position shown in the drawing. This causes de-energization of the field winding 34 to stop further opening movement of the valve i8 and to-prevent a further increase in the rate of applicationof heat to the building.

Upon' an increase in block temperature as caused by operation of the heater Bl, the slider 59 is moved to the left with respect to the coil 68 and due to the parallel relationship set out above this causes short-circuiting or shunting of the coilfie to decrease the energization thereof and increase the energization of the coil 86. This unbalanced relationship of the coils t5 and 65 causes movement of the switch arm 69 into engagement with the contact TI to complete a circuit from the secondary 76 through wires l1, l9 and 91, contacts 36 and 65, wire 98, field Winding 35, wire 99, switch arm 69, contact ll, wire 9d, a small number of turns of the coil 66, and wire 78, back to the secondary it. This causes energization of the field winding 35 to move the valve 18 towards a closed position, to move the slider 3b to the right with respect to the balancing potentiometer coil 193, and to decrease the rate of application of heat to the building.

Movement of the slider 39 to the right with respect to the balancing potentiometer coil ll] causes short-circuiting of the coil 66 to decrease the energization thereof and increase the energization of the coil 65, it being rememberedthat the coil 66 was energized more than the coil 65v by movement of the slider 59 to the left with respect to the potentiometer coil 60. When the slider 39 has moved sufficiently far to the right to re-balance the coils 55 and 66, the switch arm fit is moved out of engagement with the contact ill to the mid-positionas shown in the drawing. This causes de-energization of the field winding 35 which prevents further movement of the valve is towards a closed position to prevent a further decrease in the rate of application of heat to the building.

It will be noted that the circuits through the field windings 3d and 35 pass through a small number of turns of the coils 65 and 56. This tends to slightly increase the energization of the coils G5 or $8 to forcefully hold the switch'arm 69 into engagement with the contacts lb or H, whereby relay chatter is effectively prevented.

From the above it is seen that I have provided means whereby the valve i8 is modulated between an open and a closed position in accordance with the'position of the slider 59 with respect to the potentiometer coil 60, whereby a modulation and not an intermittent opening and closing of the valve i8 is afforded in accordance with the temperature of the block 5|.

Also mounted between the nuts 23 and 25 on the valve stem 23 is a bar 100 which may operate a variable impedance, and is shownaherein to operate a slider till, the slider being suitably insulated from the bar. The slider i! is adapted to slide across a non-linear variable resistance coil Hill. A primary Hit of a step-down transformer 104, having asecondary I is connected across the line wires 12 and. 13 by wires Hi6 and NH, respectively. One end of the secondary IE5 is connected by a wire I08 to-the large end of to Y the non-linear variable resistance coil 882. The

slider Hli associated with the variable resistance coil I02 is connected by wires I09 andv Hi} to one end of the heater 6! of the outdoor controller 5%. The other end of the heater BI is connected by a wire IH to'one end of an impedance in the form of a resistance coil H2. The other end of the resistance coil H2 is connected by a wire H3 and a fixed resistance or impedance lid to the junction of wires I09 and H0. Cooperating with the resistance coil H2 is a slider H5 and electrically connected to the slider H5 is a slider is to a center tap on the non-linear resistance I I7.

Valve I8 is so arranged that equal movements of the valve I8 toward'an open position increases in equal increments the rate of application of 7 heat to the spaces or rooms II and I 2. In order to maintain a proportional relationship between the heat imputs to the building and to the outdoor controller 50 in accordance with the heat losses from the building and the controller, which is necessary for the satisfactory operation of the control system, equal increments of heat must be added to the outdoor controller 50 upon the addition of equal increments of heat to the building. It is known that the amount of heat given off by a resistance type heater or the watts supplied thereto does not vary directly with the ourrent fiow therethrough but varies as the square of the current flow. Therefore, in order to add these equal increments of heat to the outdoor controller 50, the current flow through heater BI must be increased by decreasing increments as distinguished from equal increments. The

resistance ofthe non-linear variable resistance I02 is decreased by decreasing increments as the valve i8 is moved toward an open position by equal increments of motion. This decreasing of the resistance of the variable resistance by decreasing increments increases the current flow through the heater 6| by decreasing increments to increase the wattage and consequently the heat given off by the heater Si by equal increments, thus giving the desired control action. Therefore, with the variable resistance I02 properly designed, movement of the valve stem 2| upwardly will cause the application of proportionate amounts of heat to the outdoor controller andto the building, and likewise downward movement of the valve stem 2| will cause proportionate decreases in the amount of heat delivered to the building and to the, outdoor controller. Therefore, when the temperature of the block 5| of the outdoor controller is decreased by the action of the outdoor. atmospheric conditions, the

amount of heat delivered to the block and to the building is proportionately increased, and

likewise when the temperature of the block 5| increases due to an increase in outdoor. atmospheric conditions the amount oi heat delivered to the building and to the outdoor controller is proportionately decreased. In this manner the heater 6| and the valve I8 are modulated to maintain the temperature within the block 5| and within the building constant; which cannot be absolutely obtained by the intermittent operation of my above referred to co-pending application. r

Since the control systemof this invention is of the proportioning or modulating type and not of the intermittent type, the intermittent admission-of full charges of heating fluid to. the radiators or heat exchangers is prevented and the correct amount of heating fluid is at all times delivered thereto. ,This proves extremely bene-' ficial formild weather operation since the admission of full charges, of. heating fluid would necessarily-cause over-heating of the building during mild weather.

For purposes of illustration it is aovasae that one watt of electrical energy supplied to the outdoor controller 58 maintains the temperature thereof substantially 10 degrees above ambient. Therefore, 10 wattsmaintalns the outdoor controller 100 degrees above ambient so that if the outdoor temperature is 30 below zero, the out-' door controller 5 is maintained atsubstantially 70. Assume that the outdoor controller 50 is applied to a building having a design temperature of 30 below zero, that is when the outdoor temperature is 30 below zero, .the valve I8 must be maintained wide open to maintain the building temperature at 70. It followsthen that when the outdoor temperature is minus 30 degrees, 10 watts of electrical energy isbeing supplied to the outdoor controller 50 and the valve I8 is wide open to maintain the temperature of the outdoor controller 50 and the building at substantially.

70. As the outdoor temperature increases, the Watts 01' heat supplied to the outdoor 50 and the amount of heat delivered to the building are decreased in direct proportion to increases in -of the non-linear type as pointed out above and I it must be designed to control accurately the maximum number of watts to be supplied to the controller 50.

Assume that the outdoor controller is now applied to a building having a design temperature of zero degrees whereupon the valve I8 must be maintained wide open to maintain the temperature' of-the building at 70 when the outdoor temperature is zero degrees. .Only 7 watts need be applied to the outdoor controller to maintain the temperature thereof at 70 when the outdoor temperature is zero. -Under these conditions when the outdoor temperature is zero, the valve I8 is maintained wide open and 7 watts of electrical energy are being delivered to the outdoor controller 50. If a resistance were placed in series with the variable resistance I02 and the heater SI of the outdoor controller 50 to decrease the watts to the outdoor controller from 10 to 7 watts, an accurate control would not be obtained. As the valve I8 is'moved towards a closed position by equal increments, the wattage to the outdoor controller 50 would not be decreased by equal increments and, therefore, the proportional relationship would not be maintained. This defective mode of operation is caused by increasing the number of ohms of resistance or the load in series with the variable resistance I02. It, however, the number of ohms of resistance or the load in series with the resistance I02 is maintained constant and if the current flow through the heater 6| is adjusted in some other manner to maintain the desired wattage, the watts of the outdoor controller 50 may be caused to decrease in direct proportion to the closing of the valve 48, even though the same variable resistance I02 and the heater SI be used. This is accomplished by placing the fixed impedance or resistance III in parallel with the heater 6i, and by means oi the slider lie and the-associated resistance coil ao'zasac lid may be varied. Movement of the slider toward the right with respect to the resistance coil H2 increases the current flow through the fixed resistance M5 and decreases the current iiow through the heater (ii to decrease the'heating effect of the heater ti and in a like manner movement of the slider H5 toward the left increases the heating eiIect of the heater B l Such a construction, therefore, causes varying of the heating effect of the heater El and maintains the load on or the resistance in series with the non-- linear variable resistance Hi2 almost constant and under certain circumstances such a construction may be suficiently accurate to cause adequate operation or thetemperature control system.

In order to maintain the load on or 'the resistance in series with the resistance coil W2 absolutely constant to maintain an extremely accurate control of the temperature control system, l have provided the slider lit which cooperates with the non-linear variable resistance i ll so that movement of the slider M6 away from the center tap ofv the resistance coil 11 ll! causes increasing increments of resistance or impedance to be placed in series with the above parallel circuits. ance H2 may be calculated from the well-known reciprocal formula relating to adding resistances in parallel and a proper design of this variable resistance i ll will maintain the total impedance or resistance in series with the non-linear resistance i212 absolutely constant.

In addition to providing a modulating control of a heating system utilizing an outdoor controller having a heater, I have provided a means whereby the heating efiect or" the heater oi the outdoor controller may be accurately adjusted without rendering the system out of calibration.

Although I have shown and described one form of my invention, other forms thereof may become apparent to those slnlled in the art, and therefore this invention is to be limited only by thescope of the appended claims and the prior art.

I claim as my invention:

1. in a temperature control system of the class described, the combination of temperature changing means :for a space, a controller out- .sicle of the space and including temperature changing means and thermostatic means responsive to the temperature of the controller, the thermostatic means modulating both temperature changing means to maintain the tem- I bination of heating means for a building, an

outdoor controller subject to the same atmospheric conditions as the building, said outdoor controller including heating means and thermostatic means, the heating means of the outdoor controller and the building being proportioned to the heat losses from the building and the outdoor controller, and the thermostatic means mod- The size and shape of this variable resist ulating both of said heating means in accord ance to the heat losses from the controller to maintain the temperature in'the controller and the building constant. r

i. In a temperature control system, the combination of heating means for a'building, an. outdoor controller subject to the same atmospheric conditions as the building and including heating means and thermostatic means, the thermostatic means modulating both of said heating means in accordance with the heat losses from said controller, and means for adjusting at least one of the heating means to maintain the heat delivered to the building and to the outdoor controller proportional to the heat losses from the building and the outdoor controller.

5. In a temperature control system tor a space, the combination or" temperature changing means for the space, a controller outside of said space and including temperature changing means and thermostatically operated variable resistance means, and connections between said variable resistance means and both of said temperature changing means to modulate said temperature changing means in accordance with the temperature of said controller.

6. In a temperature control system, thecombination of heating means for a building, an outdoor controller subject to the same atmospheric conditions as the building, said outdoor controller including heating means and thermostatically operated variable resistance means, the

controlling both of said temperature changing means whereby the temperature changing means are modulated to maintain constant temperatures in the controller and space.

8. In a temperature control system, the combination of heating means for a building, an outdoor controller subject-to the same atmospheric conditions a. the building and including heating means and modulating control means responsive to the temperature of the outdoor controller, the heating means of the building and the outdoor controller being proportional to the heat losses from the building and the outdoor controller, motor means positioned by said modulating controlmeans for controlling both of said temperature changing means whereby said heating means are modulated to vary the rate of application of heat to the building and the outdoor controller.

9. In a. temperature control system for a space,

the combination of temperature changing means for the space, a controller outside of the space and including temperature changing means and thermostatic means, and connections and mechanisms between said thermostatic means and said temperature changing means for controlling the temperature changing means in re-, sponse to controller temperatures, the arrangement being such that the space temperature changing means is modulated to adjnst the them perature changing sheet cithe space tempera ture changing means.

10. In a temperaturecontrol system, the combination of heating means for a building, a controller subject to the sameatmospheric conditions as the building and including heating means and thermostatic means, and'connections and mechanisms between the thermostatic means and the heating means whereby both of the heating means are controlled by said thermostatic means, the arrangement being such that thetroller and the building, and connections and mechanisms between the thermostatic means and both of the heating means whereby the heating means are controlled by the thermostaticmeans, the arrangement being such that the building heating means is modulated to vary the rate of application of heat to the building in. accordance with the heat losses from the building as determined by outside atmospheric conditions.

12. In a temperature control system, the combination of temperature changing means for a space, a controller having temperature changing means and thermostatic means, a motor con-' ,trolling the operation of said building temperature changing means and controlled by said thermostatic means to modulate said temperature changing means, a control device also controlled 40 by said motor for modulating the controller temperature changing means whereby the temperature changing eflect oi both of said temperature changing means is varied. 13. In a temperature control system, the com- 4 bination of temperature changing means for a space, a controller having temperature changing means and thermostatic means, a motor controlling the operation of said building temperature changing means and controlled by said thermostatic means'to modulate said temperature changing means, a control device also controlledby said motor for modulating the controller temperature changing means whereby the temperaturechanging efiect of both of said tem- B peratur'e changing means is varied, and means for adjusting the temperature changing efiect of one of-said temperature changing means with rt to the other.

1%. In a temperature control system, the combination of heating means for a building, a controller subject to the same atmospheric. conditions as the building, and including heating I means and thermostatic means, motor means modulating the operation of said building heat-' ing means under the control of said thermostatic means, and control means also controlled by said motor means for modulating said controller. heating means, whereby the rate of application of heat to the building and to the con- ,troller is varied. a

15. In a temperature control system, the combination of heating means for a building, a controller subject to the-same atmospheric condiyg tions as the building and including heating means and thermostatic means, motor means modulating the operation of said building heating means under the control of said thermostatic means, control means also-controlled by said motor -means for modulating said controller heating means, whereby the rate of application of heat to the building andto the controller is varied, and means associated with one of said ing means and thermostatically operated variable resistance control means, motor means 'positioned by said thermostatically operated variable resistance control means and in control of said building heating means whereby the build== ing heating means is modulated, at variable resistance positioned by said motor means andassociated with said electric heating means whereby said electric heating means is modulated, and. means for adjusting said electric heating means to maintain the heat imputs to said controller and said building related to the heat losses from the controller'and the building.

17. In a temperature control system, the combination of heating means for a building, a controller subject to the same atmospheric condi= tions as the building and including electric heating means and thermostatically operated variable resistance control' means, motor means pcsi= tioned by said thermostatically operated variable resistance control means, and in control of said building heating means whereby the building heating means is modulated, a variable resistance positioned by said motor means and associated with said electric heating means where= by said electric heating means is modulated, and means for adjusting said electric heating means to maintain the heat imputs to said controller and said building related to the heat losses from the controller and the building, said last mentioned means including means for maintaining the load on said variable resistance substantially constant for all adjustments 18. In a temperature control system, the com bination of a controller for a heating means 111- eluding an electric heater and thermostatic means in control of the heating means, a varia= ble impedance operatedby said heating means in series with said electric heater for controlling the heating efiect of said electric heater, and

means associated with said electric heater forladjusting the heating efiect of said electric heater but maintaining the load on said variable impedance constant. I

19. In a temperature control system, the combination ofa controller for a heating means including an electric heater and thermostatic means in control of the heating means, a variable impedance operated by said heating means in series with said electric heater for controlling the heating effect of said electric heater, and means associated with said electric heater for adjusting the heating effect of said electric heater but maintaining the load on said variable impedance constant, said means including impedance means in parallel with said electric heater and means for'varying thedistribntion ofcurrent through the electric heater and the impedance means.

20. In a temperature control system, the combination of a controller for a heating means including an electric heater and thermostatic 10 means associated with said electric heater for adjusting the heating efiect of said electric heater but maintaining the load on said variable impedance constant, said means including im-' pedance means in parallel with said electric heater, means for varying the distribution of current through the electric heater and the impedance means, and means-for maintaining the total impedance associated with the variable impedance constant.

DANIEL G. TAYLOR. 

